This week’s topic was an absolute delight for me. I am a HUGE fan of old and historical homes and mansions. So much so In fact, when my husband and I got married, we honeymooned in Duluth at the historic Cotton Mansion, where I got to live out my Downton Abbey dreams. Today, we’re heading just five minutes from Duluth to Superior, WI, to explore the infamous Fairlawn Mansion.First, let's delve into the story of the remarkable individual who envisioned and constructed this astounding mansion.
The Man Behind the Mansion.
Martin Pattinson was born Simeon Martin Thayer on January 17, 1841, in southern Ontario to Simeon Martin Thayer Sr. and Emmarilla Pattison. Around the age of 11, his family moved from Canada to Sanilac County, Michigan. After spending about 10 years working in a logging camp and partnering in the lumber business near Minden, MI, with a man named Joseph Murdock, Martin married Murdock’s sister, Isabelle Murdock, on August 7, 1869. The couple welcomed their first child five months later. In 1871, two years after his marriage, Martin was elected to the Michigan State Legislature. However, the following year took a strange and somewhat scandalous turn. On April 30, 1872, Simeon Martin Thayer went to Port Huron on business and mysteriously disappeared, leaving behind his wife, Isabella, and their two children.
Coincidentally, around the same time, 18-year-old Martha Murdock, Isabella’s sister, also disappeared from Minden, MI, along with cash from the Thayer-Murdock lumber business. According to the story, Simeon Martin Thayer assumed his mother’s maiden name, becoming Martin Pattison, and moved to Marquette with Martha. Although no marriage record exists for Martin and Martha, they lived together as husband and wife until Martha's death in 1877.
Two years later, in 1879, at the age of 38, Martin met and married 23-year-old Grace E. Frink in Marquette, Michigan, making her Grace Pattison. However, Martin never divorced his first wife, Isabella, and was still legally married to her. Making Grace, unknowingly a bigamist. The laws regarding multiple marriages in the 1800s are unclear, but it's possible he was able to marry Grace under his new identity because records were not as easily accessible as they are today and no one even knew he was married. Changing one's identity was obviously much simpler without the power of the internet and social media.
The same year that Martin and Grace married, they relocated to Superior, WI, where they would eventually build the magnificent Fairlawn Mansion. Martin wasted no time establishing a logging business along the Black River, capitalizing on his extensive experience in the lumber industry. After selling his lumber interests, Martin turned his attention to the rich mineral potential of the region. He began exploring for iron ore on the Vermilion Range, and his efforts paid off handsomely. Martin successfully located the famous Chandler and Pioneer mines in Ely, MN, about two hours north of Superior. These discoveries cemented his reputation as a skilled and resourceful entrepreneur, further contributing to his legacy in the region.
Although Martin had moved and changed his name, his former brother-in-law and business partner, John Murdock, eventually tracked him down. Murdock blackmailed Martin, demanding money for his sister Isabelle and the two children Martin had abandoned. In exchange, Murdock promised to keep Martin’s double life a secret. When Martin later became wealthy and famous, Murdock demanded more—this time, a legal divorce for Isabella and a financial settlement. In June 1890, Martin agreed, and the divorce was granted.
This legal proceeding became the key to a reporter uncovering and breaking the story of Martin Pattison’s double life later that year. Interestingly, despite the scandalous revelation, the publicity did little to tarnish Pattison’s reputation. He continued to be a prominent and respected figure in the community. But the same could not be said for his personal relationships. Rumor has it that Grace, who had no knowledge of the family he had abandoned, was furious and heartbroken and from then on the two slept in separate rooms.
By this time, Martin had become a pillar of the community. He had served as Superior’s sheriff from 1885 to 1886 and held the office of mayor three times. Alongside his civic duties, Martin achieved wealth and recognition through successful ventures in logging and mining. He was also deeply involved in numerous civic organizations, including the Elks Lodge, The Odd Fellows, and the Masons.
Grace was equally influential in Superior, actively participating in civic organizations and charity groups, contributing significantly to the community alongside Martin's endeavors.
Martin and Grace Pattinson raised a family of eight children 7 girls and 1 boy: Martha, Alice, Ethel, Byron, Vyrna, Leda, Myrna, and Lois. Grace gave birth to two sets of twin girls, Myrna and Vyrna, and Leda and Lois. Tragically, Vyrna and Leda passed away in infancy, leaving six children who grew up in the Fairlawn Mansion.
The Pattinson family resided in the mansion until 1918, when Martin Pattinson passed away on December 20th in his bedroom at the age of 77 due to complications from diabetes. Grace, then 62 years old, and her youngest daughter, Lois, continued to live in the mansion until 1920. Seeking relief for Lois's rheumatoid arthritis, they relocated to Los Angeles. Grace, a woman of substantial wealth, commissioned the construction of a Tudor-style mansion known as "Windsor" on 37 acres of land. This elegant estate, not to be confused with the Winchester Mansion, served as Grace's residence until her death in 1934. After Grace's passing, Lois, her husband, and their son continued to reside at Windsor. Before leaving Superior, Grace performed one final act of unequaled generosity: she donated the beloved Fairlawn mansion to the Superior Children’s Home and Refuge Society, a charitable organization of which she was a founder and board member.
On October 13, 1920, Fairlawn Mansion opened its doors as a Children’s Home, providing shelter for orphaned or abandoned children and pregnant women. Over its operational years, the mansion housed and cared for between 40 to 50 children at a time, ultimately supporting over 2,000 children until its closure in 1962. Notably, in 1926, baseball legend Babe Ruth visited the home, bringing joy to its young residents.
The closure of the Children’s Home in 1962 was attributed to financial challenges and evolving societal norms regarding child care. Following its closure, Fairlawn Mansion faced an uncertain future. Grace Pattinson's will stipulated that if the mansion ceased to function as a children’s home, it should be demolished. However, in 1963, the City of Superior acquired Fairlawn for $12,500, aided by legal maneuvering and support from descendants of the Pattinson family.
After its purchase, Fairlawn remained vacant for several years, undergoing gradual repairs until a comprehensive restoration project began in the 1990s.
Today, Fairlawn Mansion stands as a testament to history, with its first and second floors meticulously restored to reflect the era when the Pattinson family resided there. Meanwhile, the third floor retains its original appearance from its time as a children’s home.
Today, the mansion serves as both a museum dedicated to honoring the legacy of the Pattinson family and a headquarters for the superior museum society, preserving the rich heritage of both its former inhabitants and its role as a refuge for children in need.
The Mansion Behind the Man
Martin Pattison's mansion blends elements of both Queen Anne Victorian style and French Château-esque architecture. Despite the absence of discovered blueprints and city documents lacking an architect's name, there is speculation that the house was possibly designed by John DeWaard, a prominent architect active in Superior and Duluth during the 1890s. DeWaard's craftsmanship is evident in the ornate woodwork found throughout the interior, suggesting he may have been responsible for the mansion's overall design.
Construction of the mansion commenced in 1888, with the family finally moving in by 1890, though the mansion's completion awaited until 1891. The total cost of the build was reported as $150,000, which today would equate to approximately $3.7 million. However, Grace Pattison herself indicated that the actual cost, including furnishings and mechanical equipment, was closer to $250,000, amounting to around $6.5 million in today's currency. Situated near the Duluth portage with commanding views overlooking Lake Superior and what is now Bakers Island (although not in existence at the time of construction), the mansion acquired the name Fairlawn by 1895, a moniker whose origin remains shrouded in mystery.
The mansion encompasses four floors, including a basement, with a grand total of 42 rooms, offering over 15,000 square feet of opulent living space. Each room was meticulously designed with no expense spared, boasting ornate decorations and exquisite craftsmanship.
Of particular note is the majestic corner tower crowned by an octagonal belvedere. Inside, the interior features woodwork crafted from quartersawn oak, cherry, bird’s-eye maple, and Guatemalan mahogany, showcasing the finest materials of its time. Leaded glass doors and art glass windows illuminate the rooms, while gilded swags, fluted pilasters, and elaborate fireplaces made of Egyptian marble and Mexican onyx, adorned with silver and brass trimmings, add to the mansion's lavish allure.
To truly experience the beauty of this home, tours are available year-round. Additionally, there's a concise filmed tour on YouTube by Superior Public Museums, which I'll link in the show notes. But, let me share a few fascinating details about the home with you.
When Grace and her daughter Lois relocated to California after Martin's passing, they took most of their furnishings with them. Over the years, however, many original family pieces have been generously donated back to the home. Some items are replicas or closely resemble the originals that once belonged to the family.
Among the original pieces in the home is a marble statue of Pandora, prominently displayed in the turret of Grace's former parlor. This statue was acquired in Rome during one of the Pattinson family's trips to Europe. Another cherished item is an antique grandfather clock, purchased by Martin at the World's Fair in Chicago, now gracing the landing to the second floor. Additionally, the dining room chairs bear intricate needlepoint scenes on their backs, skillfully crafted by Grace herself. These are just a few highlights among the many original items that enrich the mansion's historical ambiance.
The grand entrance of the home, embellished with expansive French glass doors, opened into a lengthy hallway flanked by rooms on either side. During its time, hallways were often seen as mere passages, but Fairlawn's first-floor corridor defied convention with its impressive length and width. Notably, it also features the main landing of an elegant oak staircase that ascends to the second floor. This spacious landing, akin to a room in its own right, is further enhanced by a fireplace, adding to the mansion's luxurious charm.
The remainder of the main floor includes a reception room, parlor, music room, formal dining room, butler’s pantry, kitchen, and Pattison’s library and office.
In the Library/Martin's Office, the bookcase proudly displays Martin's original book collections, adorned with gold-carved letters CFB, symbolizing Charity, Fellowship, and Brotherhood, integral to the Odd Fellows creed. Above the fireplace, the inscription "East or West, home is best," attributed to the Scottish poet Robert Barnes, is elegantly carved into the wood. Adjacent to this, an original stained glass window features a lamp atop a stack of books, symbolizing knowledge, with the words 'Fiat Luxe' inscribed above, meaning "Let there be light."
Music rooms were common in Victorian homes during this era, serving as hubs for familial and social music-making. Reflecting the importance of music in their lives, the Pattison family designed their music room with meticulous attention to acoustics: the ceiling was rounded to enhance sound amplification and improve acoustics. Notably, even the window behind the piano is crafted from curved glass, enhancing the room's aesthetic and acoustic qualities.
The music room transitions into a small area known as the conservatory, although this space is not original to the mansion. Initially, it served as the passageway to a large steel and glass greenhouse that Martin Pattison stocked with thousands of dollars' worth of exotic plants, fruits, and vegetables. Sadly, the greenhouse was demolished in 1930 during the children's home era. The current conservatory, constructed after its removal, later served as a dentist's office during that period.
That wasn't the only thing removed during the children's home era. Interestingly enough all the fireplaces on the second floor, all but 2, were removed and stored in the basement, as they were deemed unsafe for children. Understandably. As well as the coach house which the gift shop stands today.
Other amenities included in the original construction of Fairlawn Mansion were ahead of their time. These features showcased Martin Pattison's forward-thinking approach to comfort and convenience. Alongside indoor plumbing with hot-and-cold running water, the mansion boasted chandeliers equipped with both electricity and gas for reliability during power outages (as electricity was still fairly new at this time), a total of nine gas fireplaces complemented by two wood-burning ones, steam heating, an electric dumbwaiter, a central vacuum system, and an air shaft that circulated air throughout the entire house via a fan. Pattison even installed skylights in the attic roof to enhance natural lighting.
Beyond these innovations, the basement housed a bowling alley and plunge pool, while the third floor accommodated a billiard room and ballroom. Each of these features contributed to making Fairlawn Mansion not only a luxurious residence but also a marvel of architectural ingenuity for its time.
There's much more to discover within the walls of this historic home, that you will have to see for yourself.
Are there still residents “Living” in the house?
Rumors and tales circulate about Fairlawn Mansion, with many suggesting it is home to numerous spirits. Megan Meyer, the Executive Director of Superior Public Museums, reflects, "I firmly believe there’s an energy to this building. How could it not hold echoes of its storied past, having experienced so much over the years? I think people have left their mark on this place, and that’s what we feel, hear, and experience here."
For many, including the museum's staff, the presence of these spirits is more than just a feeling—it's a tangible part of the mansion's ongoing legacy.
“Most popular thing that people talk about it smelling cigar smoke. An old home does give off a lot of different smells throughout the time, throughout the years, the seasons what not, but cigar smoke it kind of the one that tends to stick around. Personally, I’ve heard footsteps, previous staff have had the same experience,” Meyer explained.
There have also been reports of lingering perfume in the air, along with sightings of a ghost believed to be that of a servant girl. According to local lore, this servant worked at fairlawn and lived with her husband. Tragically, she was allegedly murdered by her husband, and it is said that her spirit returns to Fairlawn because it was where she felt most comfortable in life. Visitors have reported encounters where she acts like an employee, helping patrons by directing them to facilities and assisting lost children in finding their parents.
The Pattisons were known for their exceptional treatment of staff, reflecting their generosity and community spirit, which may have contributed to the servant girl's attachment to Fairlawn Mansion even in death.
While there are no confirmed reports of children dying in the home during its time as a children's home, as those records are sealed, speculation persists. One enduring rumor suggests that a little girl tragically drowned in the pool. Contrary to this tale, the pool was actually drained long before the home became a children's facility and remains intact today, repurposed as a storage room. Visitors have reported hearing the giggles and laughter of small children echoing throughout the mansion.
Megan Meyer firmly asserts her belief in the presence of spirits within the home, but reassures that they are benign. According to her, there have been no reports of anything sinister or frightening occurring within the mansion's walls.
However, if you're skeptical, you can join their flashlight tours where the lights are dimmed, and guides share stories about the resident ghosts and Victorian lore. It's an experience I'm definitely adding to my bucket list!
In addition to the flashlight tours, as I mentioned earlier, they offer guided tours throughout the year to explore this magnificent home.
While you're in the area, don't miss Pattison State Park, which has preserved Big Manitou Falls for a century. Martin Pattison secretly purchased 660 acres along the Black River in 1917 to prevent the construction of a power dam that would have destroyed the falls. His donation of the land in 1918 ensured the preservation of the waterfall and its surrounding property. Martin expressed his deep connection to the falls, stating:
"In being able to gift this site to the public, I have fulfilled one of my greatest ambitions. I have spent many years enjoying the surroundings of the falls, and it has become an integral part of my life."
With his generous act, Martin Pattison ensured that the waterfall, which had been attracting people for centuries, would not be lost. Wisconsin dedicated its sixth state park on January 20, 1920, thanks to his donation of land. With such a rich history of its own, I'm strongly considering dedicating an entire post solely to exploring the park.
But until that time. Go explore these rich places of history for yourself.
Sources:
YouTube- The Fairlawn Mansion Tour- Superior Public Museum-The Fairlawn Mansion Tour
SAH Archipedia-FAIRLAWN MANSION, MARTIN AND GRACE PATTISON HOUSE-Marsha Weisiger https://sah-archipedia.org/buildings/WI-01-DG6
Northern News Now-Holding On To History: The legacy of Martin and Grace Pattison lives on-By Dave Anderson Published: Dec. 18, 2023 - https://www.northernnewsnow.com/2023/12/19/holding-history-legacy-martin-grace-pattison-lives/
Geni- Genealogy of Simeon Martin Thayer- Eric Orner- https://www.geni.com/people/Simeon-Pattison/6000000033147768881
Superior Public Museums- MARTIN PATTISON - THE GREAT LUMBER BARON- by Martha Sheibe-https://superiorpublicmuseums.org/january-2020/
1889 VICTORIAN HOUSE RESTORATION- Fairlawn Mansion- From Zenithcity.com and written by Judith Liebaert Original link here: Superiors American Castle- http://1889victorianrestoration.blogspot.com/2016/03/fairlawn-mansion.html
SSWDA- The Double Life of Martin Pattison (1841 to 1872; 1872 to 1918)- https://www.sswda.org/archive/the-double-life-of-martin-pattison-1841-to-1872-1872-to-1918/
Northern News Now- Historic mansion plays important role in Superior's history- By Izabella Zadra Published: Jul. 12, 2024- https://www.northernnewsnow.com/2024/07/12/historic-mansion-plays-important-role-superiors-history/
Fox 21 Local News- The Ghosts of Fairlawn Mansion in Superior-September 26, 2022 by Cam Derr- https://www.fox21online.com/2022/09/26/the-ghosts-of-fairlawn-mansion-in-superior/
Wisconsin Haunted Houses- Fairlawn Mansion and Museum - Superior WI Real Haunted Places- https://www.wisconsinhauntedhouses.com/real-haunt/fairlawn-mansion-museum.html
Lost in the States- Fairlawn Mansion- Posted on August 22, 2023 by Mike Sonnenberg- https://lostinthestates.com/fairlawn-mansion/
Wisconsin Department of Natural Recourses- History Pattison State Park-https://dnr.wisconsin.gov/topic/parks/pattison/history